Gibbs Reflective Cycle for Coaches: Six Stages with Examples

What Is the Gibbs Reflective Cycle?

Graham Gibbs developed his reflective cycle in 1988 as a way to turn experience into learning. It is one of the most widely used reflection frameworks in professional development, and it appears in most FA and UEFA coaching qualification programmes because it works.

The cycle has six stages, each with a specific purpose. Moving through all six stops coaches from simply replaying events and pushes them to extract actual learning and commit to change.

The Six Stages

Stage 1: Description

What happened?

Describe the session or incident objectively. Stick to the facts. Who was there? What was the activity? What happened? Avoid analysis or judgement at this stage.

Example: "Tuesday evening. U13s training session. Working on positional play in a 4-3-3 shape. 14 players present. The session ran for 75 minutes including a possession-based rondo, a positional game, and a match. Two players arrived 15 minutes late."

Stage 2: Feelings

What were you thinking and feeling?

Be honest about your emotional response. Coaches often skip this stage because it feels uncomfortable. It is the most useful.

Example: "I felt flustered when the two players arrived late because it disrupted the rondo setup. I felt the session was going well during the positional game but deflated when the match became chaotic. I was unsure whether to stop and reorganise or let it run."

Stage 3: Evaluation

What was good and bad about the experience?

Assess what worked and what did not. This is a balanced appraisal, not a list of problems.

Example: "Good: the rondo generated lots of quality touches and the players were focused. The late arrivals were handled without disrupting everyone else. Poor: I let the match run too long hoping players would self-organise. They did not. I gave too many interventions in the final 10 minutes, most of which the players ignored."

Stage 4: Analysis

Why did things happen the way they did?

This is where genuine reflection starts. Push past symptoms to causes.

Example: "The chaos in the match happened because the positional game before it had no transition element — players did not know where to be when possession switched. The interventions were ignored because I was addressing the whole group rather than individual pairs. Players in this age group respond better to targeted, private coaching points."

Stage 5: Conclusion

What else could you have done?

Identify alternatives to what you actually did. This stage prevents you from defaulting to the same approach next time.

Example: "I could have added a transition trigger to the positional game. I could have set a maximum match time with a built-in reset rather than letting it run indefinitely. I could have used freeze coaching to pause the game and work with one pair at a time."

Stage 6: Action Plan

What will you do next time?

Commit to specific, observable changes. Vague conclusions do not become better coaching.

Example: "Next positional session: add a transition rule where the team in possession must track back when they lose the ball. Cap the final match at 12 minutes. Use freeze coaching for individual corrections — one pair at a time, private, specific."

Why Gibbs Works for Coaches

The cycle forces specificity at every stage. Coaches who only work through stages 1-3 (description, feelings, evaluation) are not actually reflecting — they are reviewing. The analysis and action plan stages are what convert experience into learning.

Gibbs also helps coaches notice patterns over time. If Stage 2 keeps showing frustration with late arrivals, or Stage 4 keeps identifying the same session design problem, those patterns are worth addressing at a structural level.

CoachReflection's AI conversation mode guides you through the key elements of Gibbs automatically. You do not need to know the stages by name — just answer the questions, and the structure handles itself.

FAQ

How long does a Gibbs reflection take?

A written reflection working through all six stages takes about 10-15 minutes for a typical session. The depth of analysis in stages 4-6 is what takes time — stages 1-3 can be done in under five minutes.

Do I need to use all six stages every time?

Yes, ideally. Coaches who skip stages 4-6 often find themselves making the same mistakes repeatedly because they never get to the "why" or the "what next." That said, a brief five-stage reflection is better than no reflection at all.

Is Gibbs accepted as CPD evidence?

Yes. Structured reflective practice using a recognised framework like Gibbs is accepted as CPD evidence by the FA, UEFA, and most other governing bodies, provided entries are dated and demonstrate learning.

---

[CoachReflection](https://coachreflection.com/signup?utm_source=blog&utm_medium=article&utm_campaign=gibbs) guides coaches through structured reflection after every session. Free to start.